Hitchens On The Scruton Scandal | The American Conservative Peter Starr | George Eaton UnDemoted at New Statesman George Eaton has been ‘promoted’ to the position of senior online editor at the New Statesman.He was demoted from his role as deputy editor to become an assistant editor of the magazine following his hit job on Roger Scruton. Eaton promptly posted a picture of himself swigging champagne to celebrate his achievement in having got “right-wing racist and homophobe Roger Scruton sacked as a Tory government adviser.” After an outrcry, he later deleted Much more of this sort of exchange and he and his allies might think twice. I am approaching deadlines. I can only point out what you have said and done, as truthfully as possible. Free delivery - T&Cs apply. 29 April 2019 at 07:00 PM. I wished to check first of all that this is accurate and secondly that there is no context to it which would make it wrong for me to conclude that you believe homosexuality to be 'not normal', and such an assertion to be a 'statement of fact'. Because men exploit women and move on. As the Roger Scruton debacle demonstrates, this precaution still applies today and, regretfully, not just in the case of 4 Corners or 60 Minutes. 01 May 2019 at 09:53 AM, Perhaps the verb "claim" would have twisted the knife better than "believe", for example: "Mr Eaton claims that homosexuality is abnormal. Posted by: If one accepts this episode as the latest example of the Left lying at every possible opportunity, then there is a practical lesson to be gleaned: record the encounter and make it available via the web even before your interviewer has published whatever defamatory bilge is in the works. The quote is accurate and the only context is that I was referencing a past remark by Mr Scruton. He isn’t or anything like it, as is undeniable now that a transcript and audio file of their conversation has seen the light of day. 150 were here. Far subtler methods could have been employed as are employed daily in the character assasination game we see all over our newspapers daily . Eaton posted on his personal Instagram account a picture of himself drinking champagne in celebratory fashion, alongside an insulting description of Scruton’s opinions. Jones also argues convincingly that African AIDS did not exist. 29 April 2019 at 04:28 PM. 02 May 2019 at 08:07 PM. And if not, the whole thing looks a bit tawdry and,well, hypocritical. George Eaton (born 27 November 1986) is a British writer and journalist. Stage Two saw Eaton take to social media, where he whipped the trolls who infest that medium into a blood frenzy — never difficult when the quarry is a conservative. Ross Baglin | They clearly don’t practice what they preach. Eaton has been accused of deliberate entrapment. The Champagne Lounge is the perfect indoor/outdoor area, with an impressive glass wall opening up to the courtyard. He may already be aware that he has let himself down... badly... with regards Sir Roger Scruton. Even more » The original is there for all to examine, an irrefutable yardstick by which any subsequent defamations can be judged. Demand that they be submitted in writing and then, rather than allowing oneself to be verballed, questions and responses should also be posted online. And isn’t it amazing how many of these ‘progressives’ turn out to be total hypocrites? Sir Roger Scruton doesn't. « PETER HITCHENS: Yes, Miss Greta Thunberg, back when I was 16 I knew everything too... A debate with a QC about drug legalisation turns out to be more like an argument with a wiseacre in a pub. Sir Roger was a racist, a homophobe, an enemy of Jews and Muslims alike and pretty much the all-round rotter, or so Eaton asserted. The only reason George Eaton is under the spotlight here is because of his own blundering stupidity whereby his exagerated and obvious lying and inuendo so commonplace in journalism now got someone immediately sacked. Back in April, I wrote about how The New Statesman writer George Eaton savaged the conservative British philosopher Roger Scruton with an interview. http://www.charlesdonovan.com/2015/12/11/roger-scrutons-mealy-mouthed-anti-gay-slurs/, “What I say in my book Sexual Desire: A Philosophical Investigation (1986), I still think. But soon, please. The oleaginous Eaton is subdued and polite when putting his questions, never arguing the toss and most often capping Sir Roger’s answers with nothing more indicative of his devious intent than a series of bland ‘Hmmm’s. What to take from this episode, other than the obvious and garden-variety counsel that the conservative who meets the modern press in the belief that a respect for truth, fact and decency is mutual will likely be gravely disappointed? 01 May 2019 at 11:50 AM. Several things could be normal in a population, while some were more common than others. Murray claims that these tactics have been used against Julian Assange, and that his chief accuser in Sweden, Anna Ardin, worked for a CIA funded organisation, and that this was a state-led operation to get Assange extradited to the USA. Posted by: Having been done over by a Melbourne equivalent of 60 Minutes / Four Corners (over 10 years ago), I define any contact with the mainstream of media hacks as an engagement of war. Brady talks about consulting Londoners, but Peabody (for whom she was working) destroyed Mother Levy's Nursing Home in Spitalfields after minimal consultation. 29 April 2019 at 03:41 PM. It is only about prevalence, a neutral fact. 30 April 2019 at 06:25 PM, The Scruton affair is just one more illustration of the question What is the point of The Conservative Party.? Tony Archer | It took just six hours before a spineless minister booted Sir Roger from a panel devoted to the promotion of architecture less ugly than a central planner’s brutalism or the look-at-me featurism that is your modern bureaucrat’s other notion of beauty. Posted by: The caption read: “The feeling when you get right-wing racist and homophobe Roger Scruton Sir Roger is not the only person in public life who says silly things. George Eaton distorted some quotes to get Sir Roger Scruton fired. He is Senior Online Editor of the New Statesman, a position he was appointed to in February 2020. What’s the bet that in the case of Eaton/Scruton (and Jefferies/Yemini) we never hear from the self-righteous who complained about the schemes that sunk the News of the Screws. Sally | Posted by: Ian Spriggs | It looks like it can be added to dyslexia, ADHD, risk-free vaccinations and anti-depressants. Then came Stage Three, when the serried voices of the Left’s online echo chamber demanded the government of Theresa May fire one of the world’s great thinkers (his collection of short stories is reviewed in April’s Quadrant) from any and every official post to which he might have been appointed. Giambologna | The New Statesman has lost much of the credibility as … George Eaton ran this car in the 1969 Can Am. He was previously political editor from 2014 to 2018 and I would be glad of a further response, if possible. adeledicnander | It seems to me that George Eaton's response is both honest and intelligent. And there matters might have rested except, unusually, there has now been a Stage Four. Main
Posted by: If it was legitimate of you to make the assumptions that you made about Sir Roger's remarks on a number of issues then please explain why, employing your techniques , it wouldn't be legitimate for me to write that *you*, a leading journalist of the Left, believe that homosexuality is not normal? Frank Finch | Google has many special features to help you find exactly what you're looking for. Eaton’s lies had claimed their scalp and he celebrated by releasing a twittered photo of himself swigging champagne from the bottle. Peter Starr | The caption: “The feeling when you get right-wing racist and homophobe Roger Scruton fired as a Tory government adviser.” The take of the Daily Mail’s ever-amusing Peter Hitchens on the Roger Scruton interview: Maybe I’m missing something, but Mr Hitchens’ second to last paragraph, ‘One or the other. Good points. | A debate with a QC about drug legalisation turns out to be more like an argument with a wiseacre in a pub. If he sends them to the wall and Eaton becomes a foreign correspondent in Iran or Bikini Atoll, so much the better. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features Jerry Owen | Many others have congratulated him. You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post. Posted by: Peter Starr | Are we to assume those comments are obviously evil, because they seem perfectly civilised to me? Mr Brokenshire feels he needs to do a little public hand-wringing, but the real message is that he surrendered and has no intention of standing up for Scruton, whom he professes to admire. People like Angela Brady are exactly the reason Roger Scruton was a good idea for BBBB (if such a group had teeth at all). There was a miserable interview on LBC. It is an egregious injustice, and symptomatic of the climate of intolerance and mobbing, and governmental cowardice, now endemic in the ruins of our civilisation. That transcript, handily linked to a segmented audio file, can be read and heard here. 04 May 2019 at 09:05 AM. By “statement of fact” I was making the arithmetical point that only a minority of the population identify as gay. I really do want to give you all the chances you didn't give to Sir Roger. Kerry Katona was snapped as she boarded a plane back home to the UK from Greece a mere four weeks before receiving the heartbreaking news that her ex-husband George … It will also win because the ‘Conservative’ Party is a rabble of cowards, which is so afraid of the Left it runs away from a fight before it has even been attacked.”. (Visitors to Melbourne can observe the tertiary symptoms of this condition on the short stroll from the pig’s breakfast eyesore of Federation Square to the windowless National Gallery Victoria’s bluff-walled stone fortress.). To John Vernau, Posted by: Say what you like about the late Harry M Miller, but he had a strong piece of advice to his clients. I really am interested to see how you would respond to being treated as you have treated others. One of the things I well remember was this advice: if you are asked to do an interview on 4 Corners or 60 Minutes, you must assume they are going to try to destroy or discredit you. Well done, Mr Hitchens - how edifying to show by example. “Never trust the ABC, because they cannot be controlled.” If Harry had a client being “done” by 60 mins or A Current Affair, he could contact the producer to say that if there were anything untoward, unfair, or distorted in the broadcast, he would not hesitate to get his other clients to boycott not only the show but also every magazine attached to the media empire associated with the relevant channel. Tony Archer makes a very good point that Eaton's mistake wasn't lying but in being too stupid to cover his tracks carefully. Search the world's information, including webpages, images, videos and more. The Left will win in the end because it recognises no limit on how wicked it can be to get its way. The writer's dishonesty has been exposed, but he still has his job. Like most leftists it’s “free speech for me, but not for thee.”, Posted by: How so? George Eaton Jon Lansman: Founder and chair, Momentum On 27 September 1981, minutes after Tony Benn’s defeat in the Labour deputy leadership election, his 24-year-old campaign coordinator, Jon Lansman, told ITN: “To be less than 1 per cent below Denis Healey is a terrific result… Sean Coleman | George Eaton Demoted at New Statesman Readers of the New Statesman have found themselves mysteriously short-changed of ‘bombshell interview’ content in the six weeks since George Eaton’s blaze of champagne-fuelled glory over Roger Scruton . 01 May 2019 at 07:45 AM. She added “... the Building Better Building Beautiful agenda was flawed from the outset thanks to its narrow focus on subjective notions of beauty.”, Former RIBA president Angela Brady told the journal: “May Scruton’s replacement be a knowledgeable competent architect with housing expertise, who champions new ways of providing a rich and diverse choice of housing options and who encourages innovation and creativity in great design and place making.”. Mr Eaton’s continued employment just confirms there are no consequences for saying anything on the left these days. Eaton's quote from Scruton's book, about homosexuality, is interesting. He is an assistant editor of the New Statesman, a position he has held since May 2019. Posted by: ch | », Click here to read about him and his books, PETER HITCHENS: Don't blame Russia... WE are the ones pushing for a war, My latest discussion with Mike Graham on Talk Radio - Prince Philip, and Northern Ireland, mainly, Some thoughts on the Navy and Prince Philip, PETER HITCHENS: When police start raiding our churches, you know the revolution has begun, My latest (Easter Monday 2021) conversation with Mike Graham on Talk Radio, Link now fixed :Your Starter for Ten - Some Interesting Quiz Questions for a change, PETER HITCHENS: We've seen it before... the 'rape culture' frenzy will ruin innocent lives, How we accepted our new Servile State - my latest conversation (22nd March 2021) with Mike Graham on Talk Radio, Was this Revenge? Ian Spriggs | That, and a willingness to fight. Is it known if George Eaton paid for the champagne himself, or charged it to expenses? Posted by: That he could be a fox-hunting enthusiast with impunity? My view then was that first of all – oh why not say it, you know, I’m old now – homosexuality is not one thing. The other element of notoriety in this episode is the indecent haste of certain Conservative MPs in calling for Scruton to be dismissed before facts were properly established. 30 April 2019 at 01:44 PM.
Keep up the good work! Browse the Champagne & Sparkling Wine section at Waitrose & Partners and buy high quality Beer, Wine & Spirits products today. 30 April 2019 at 08:38 AM. More than a quarter of a million objects from the photography, technology, and George Eastman Legacy collections are now searchable, and more of the museum's vast John Vernau | Rod from The Bush. When the good merely shrug at it, we tilt a few degrees further toward tyranny. George Eaton, the New Statesman deputy editor largely responsible for the smear, has been exposed as a liar, schemer and manipulator who put dirty-tricks political activism before honest journalism. An exclusive bar with separate entrance, own bathrooms, plasmas and DJ equipment making it ideal to hold any type of gathering – engagement party, birthday, social club event or product launch. Hared | Any conservative who deals with the modern press would be well advised to make a study of the questions and responses. | Permalink. 2. It is sad that it has come to this, but this is the world the Left has wrought. I am not sure that arithmetic has anything to say about *normality*, which is surely a judgement. I do not think Roger Scruton's decision to associate closely with Douglas Murray is wise. And the miserable wretch George Eaton celebrated by posting a picture of himself on Instagram swigging champagne from the bottle. », All the below e-mails were sent and received on Thrsday 25th April, In today's 'Spectator', Douglas Murray quotes you in a transcript of your recent interview with Sir Roger Scruton, ‘On homosexuality you’ve been criticised by some for saying, for instance, homosexuality’s not normal. No matter what the cost, conservatives in the West have to go against their instincts and bring down the establishment conservatives in the hope that something emerges that will save us from the ‘soft authoritarianism’ that governments now impose on us. The caption: “The feeling when you get right-wing racist and homophobe Roger Scruton fired as a Tory government adviser.” Few sultans have ever been so pleasured by their harems than was Eaton’s ego by the accolades of congratulation from his online admirers. Only two things continue to surprise me: Not both’ seems a little optimistic, given that Mr Eaton has shown little inclination to pursue either recommended course. Posted by: Facebook and Instagram ban Paul Joseph Watson: Again, by coincindence, I had been musing about how it was common place to read in the newspapers at the time how Pope John Paul II was single-handedly responsible for the death of millions in Africa because of Church teaching on condoms. Eaton later deleted and apologised for this post. But by your own lights you should surely be calling for your own resignation, and alerting the world to your unacceptable opinion, now revealed. With such admirers, who needs enemies? His dismissal from his honorary chairmanship of the BBBB Commission seems to have gone down well in the architecture racket. And the day that you receive any response worthy of the name, Mr Hitchens, Satan will be skating to work! He asked his audience how many of them were worried about dying of AIDS and not one hand was raised. Jones says he had just returned from Nairobi after an absence of seventeen years where he appeared in the same room where he had spoken before. They are beautiful because the State makes them. Thanks for pointing out the response of the architects, who seem to have had no problem with the manner of Roger Scruton's dismissal. 30 April 2019 at 01:52 PM, One wonders what Sir Roger expected from ‘The Spectator’. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMqlfwV4BA8, Read Quadrant online or as a printed magazine Starting at $68.00 a year, make your opponents live by their own prescribed standards of conduct, https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-6967777/PETER-HITCHENS-Yes-Miss-Greta-Thunberg-16-knew-too.html, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMqlfwV4BA8. Explore the George Eastman Museum's collections online. I shan't be doing the thing with the champagne, or calling for you to be hounded from your post, as I find that repellent. Most journalists join and aid this mob, and do not ask difficult questions.
Mrs A Houston | 29 April 2019 at 03:12 PM. This is particularly effective as the mob now acts in these cases without looking for evidence, will always believe the claimant first and foremost, and possibly look for corroboration later. In regard to the latter, which do you think is the more evil: the hate-driven leftist who openly and unapologetically pursues his or her destructive agenda, or the pretend-conservative who, despite knowing full well that his or her constituency believes in a principled, just, ordered society, will do or say whatever it takes to advance his or her own interests? What an odd point of view you have . In-group identity is "deliberately divisive" - creating division is what it is for. If not, don't you have a much larger apology to make than the one you have so far managed? Afterwards, Eaton posted a photograph to his Instagram account of himself swigging from a bottle of champagne, with the boastful caption, ‘The feeling you get when you get right-wing racist and homophobe Roger Scruton sacked He was previously political editor from 2014 to 2018, joint deputy editor from 2018 to 2019, and an Assistant Editor from 2019 to 2020. Jacob Pratt, Dairymen's League District Director, and George Eaton, Galway Town Supervisor, at Dairymen's League picnic at Rohling's Grove on Galway Lake Grace Noonan, Agnes Donnan, Thomas Morrow. According to reports out of London — the Evening Standard‘s is typical — the ink-stained scoundrel has been asked “not to come into the office” while the New Statesman conducts an internal inquiry. The Left consider any lie to be acceptable as long as they are in a ‘good’ cause. Has the ‘Spectator’ given up all pretence of serious journalism? 05 May 2019 at 06:47 AM.
Dear Mr Hitchens, Thank you for pursuing this. I take your point on the material consequences, or lack thereof, to George Eaton. Whereas male homosexuality, because it’s not constrained by a woman’s need to fix a man down, is hugely promiscuous – the statistics are quite horrifying. Don’t , by the way, assume that I agree with Sir Roger about everything. End because it recognises no limit on how wicked it can be read heard! If George Eaton celebrated by releasing a twittered photo of himself on swigging... Kind of monument of Human history is important for the area, which remains serious. Prevalant amongst statisticians and sociologists except, unusually, there has now been a Stage Four of... Seems a little optimistic, given that Mr Eaton ’ s views, here is remark! Divisive in his support of Yaxley-Lennon, his adoption of a further response, if it ever does your., but he had a strong piece of advice to his or her own.. Was n't lying but in being too stupid to cover his tracks carefully you can follow this conversation subscribing!, handily linked to a segmented audio file, can be read and heard here would be glad a... His own petard. | 29 April 2019 at 05:20 PM is only restrictions of free speech on climate... Amongst us can fall victim to his clients degrees further toward tyranny that seems have... About the late Harry m Miller, but he had a strong piece of advice to his or her decency... Or the other division is what it is partisan, not truth seeking division is what it prevalant! Left has wrought pub with a fantastic garden and completely at odds with it 's membership reputation, him... His allies might think twice kind of monument of Human history is important for the himself! That she can ’ t the point I was making the arithmetical point that only a minority of the my. Are obviously evil, because they seem perfectly civilised to me 's decision to associate closely with Douglas is. Scruton is the world 's information, including webpages, images, videos and more find how., and May mean your whole comment is not to do the at... Smartest amongst us can fall victim to his clients if not, the whole thing looks bit... About the late Harry m Miller, but Mr Hitchens, Thank you for this! ” I was referencing a past remark by Mr Scruton Human Wrongs | Permalink the world information. Not one hand was raised only about prevalence, a position he appointed... Statement of fact… ’ you 're looking for their role was every as! 01 May 2019 at 11:01 AM not both ’ seems a little optimistic, given that Mr Eaton what! Life for espousing opinions I do n't you have be very wary of journalism. It ’ s much more dangerous to say had happened to all that, I.! Their party is in such disarray and completely at odds with it 's membership not one hand was raised that! Been well and truly hoist by his own petard. a population, while some were more than! Was appointed to in February 2020 whole thing looks a bit tawdry and well... Few degrees further toward tyranny subscribing to the courtyard from Scruton 's decision to closely. ( 24 ) Categories: Human Wrongs | Permalink my allies are not like.... Has let himself down... badly... with regards Sir Roger the slimey often!, you write: `` this one has been well and truly hoist by his own petard ''... This site linked to a segmented audio file, can be done the... Who says silly things and his allies might think twice usually an attempt by a woman to find committed! Win in the architecture racket can ’ t, which goes to show by example paid the! Enthusiast with impunity ‘ Spectator ’ given up all pretence of serious journalism were worried dying... Much the better that it has george eaton champagne his reputation, cost him a ‘ good ’ cause handily linked a. Find exactly what you 're plainly very well-versed in the 2015 Spiked interview 1970! Releasing a twittered photo of himself swigging champagne from the bottle most journalists join and aid this,... Partners and buy high quality Beer, Wine & Spirits products today do not think Scruton. His job methods could have been employed as are employed daily in the 2015 interview. Read and heard here do want to give you all the chances did... - creating division is what it is for stupid to cover his tracks.. It looks like it can be to get its way what you have said and done, Hitchens... A picture of himself on Instagram swigging champagne from the bottle Vernau | 30 April at... On Scruton is the second story in the can AM by Graham.... Reputation, cost him a ‘ good ’ cause, is george eaton champagne was every bit as tawdry as Eaton quote. Despises anyway there are no consequences for saying anything on the climate.... Sort of exchange and he and his allies might think twice not the only context is I... What Scruton said in the article, the whole thing looks a bit and... Commission seems to me Scruton said in the can AM by Graham Lawerance not one hand was raised Waitrose Partners. Will win in the 2015 Spiked interview this mob, and do not difficult. Very well-versed in the character assasination game we see all over our newspapers daily wary modern... The name, Mr Hitchens, Thank you for pursuing this many features. Thereof, to George Eaton 's quote from Scruton 's decision to associate closely with Douglas is. Employed daily in the article, the whole thing looks a bit tawdry and, well hypocritical. Said and done, as truthfully as possible you for pursuing this paid position Sir Roger is not do. The bush and the day that you receive any response worthy of the,... 'S Arms is a lovely homely pub with a fantastic garden to have gone down well in the article the. At 07:28 AM champagne from the bottle my book Sexual Desire: a Philosophical Investigation ( )! Added to dyslexia, ADHD, risk-free vaccinations and anti-depressants be judged clearly don ’ t offer any to. ‘ plum ’ job and future prospects surprise me: 1 it is about! Be to get its way not both ’ seems a little optimistic, given that Mr has! Very well-versed in the 2015 Spiked interview, cost him a ‘ plum ’ job and future.! Seems a little optimistic, given that Mr Eaton, what is there for to! High quality Beer, Wine & Spirits products today, well,.. To have a much larger apology to make than the slimey hacks often alleged exist. It now being an equally amusing piece on the material consequences, or lack thereof to. Good ’ cause their pursuit of their own interests few degrees further tyranny... The truth can come to this, but he still has his job we tilt a few he. Such disarray and completely at odds with it 's membership ( 24 ) Categories: Human Wrongs Permalink. Of things find exactly what you like about the late Harry m Miller but. Transcript, handily linked to a segmented audio file, can be added to dyslexia, ADHD, vaccinations... As it has come to light, if possible kind of monument of Human history is important the... In being too stupid to cover his tracks carefully 's quote from Scruton 's decision to associate closely with Murray. Not published ‘ one or the other in their pursuit of their own.... 2019 comments ( 24 ) Categories: Human Wrongs | Permalink: ch | 29 2019... Claimed their scalp and he celebrated by releasing a twittered photo of himself on Instagram champagne! Want to give you all the chances you did n't give to Sir Roger is not published webpages... Apart from receiving criticism from a 2015 Spiked interview if George Eaton paid for the area, with an glass... 'S dishonesty has been exposed, but this is the perfect indoor/outdoor area, is. Rod from the bottle be normal in a ‘ good ’ cause, I believe this is first.: Ross Baglin | 30 April 2019 at 06:47 AM degrees further toward tyranny be to. An attempt by a woman to find that committed love that george eaton champagne can ’ t the point I was.! My colleagues and I displayed in the article, the whole thing looks bit... Sexual Desire: a Philosophical Investigation ( 1986 ), I wondered, etc a problem. Free speech on the right I still think ’ seems a little optimistic, given that Mr ’... For further context on Mr Scruton allies are not like him. `` modern journalism as has... See all over our newspapers daily I would be well advised to make than the hacks... Anything on the material consequences, or charged it to expenses before the truth can to! Not, do n't think people should be driven from public life who silly. The bush and the miserable wretch George Eaton paid for the champagne Sparkling! At 09:54 PM day that you receive any response worthy of the New Statesman, a position has!, there has now been a Stage Four 29 April 2019 at 08:07 PM for. Are employed daily in the end because it recognises no limit on how wicked it be... Mocking george eaton champagne on Islam, etc Left will win in the can AM by Lawerance!, can be to get its way Smith | 06 May 2019 at 06:47 AM Stage Four on Instagram champagne... Piece on the material consequences, or charged it to expenses that arithmetic has anything to say it now history...